Forums » Backgammon
Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair
Replies: 13 Pages: 1 Most recent reply posted by: lechacal999 (Feb 1, 2016 12:09 AM) | | Welcome, Guest | | Login | | Guest Settings |
|
- M.flyordie Backgammon
- Play Backgammon Online Against People
- Technical problems with FlyOrDie Games: 1,854 / 7,389 Feb 3, 2021 11:48 AM Forum games Create your own forum game: 79 / 924 Dec 7, 2020 1:44 PM FlyOrDie Games: Billiards: 4,478 / 37,883 Feb 7, 2021 1:33 PM Chess: 1,058 / 3,711.
- Backgammon requires you to move your checkers after a roll of two dice. The number of dots on each die dictate your options. For example, if you roll a five and a one, you must move a checker five points forward, and a second checker one point forward.
10,609 likes 4 talking about this. FlyOrDie multiplayer games: 3D Billiards -Sports games-Board games- Tanx -Boulder dash games.
| Reply to this Topic | Post New Topic | Search Forum |
lechacal999
Posts: 1
Registered: Nov, 2015
|
| | Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Feb 1, 2016 12:09 AM |
| | I was playing a 10 points match and the other player was leading 6-1. In the following game, i got an amazing advantage. The cube value was 4. He had 3 mens on my 2 point and 4 mens on the bar and was behind at least 100 points in the pips count. His homebord was weak (only made 3 points). 14 of my checkers were on my home board and i had made the 1,3,4,5 and 6 point. My last checker was on his way to my homeboard.
Then he resign and i got 8 points for a gammon (2 for gammon multipliate by 4 for the cube value). I had really REALLY good backgammon chances (with 7 of his checkers on my homeboard or on the bar) which would had make me win the match (13-6) right away. Instead i get a 9-6 lead but he make a comeback (in a doubtful way, see below) and i lost the match.
He double the next game (which did not respect the Crawford rule) and win a gammon so he win 10-9.
So, i lost the match because i did not get my backgammon points (REALLY unfair), AND the Crawford rule was not applied, which is also REALLY unfair. 2 rules not applied in the same match to make me lose. All this is a total joke and is an insult to the spirit of the game.
Other situation : i had 12 checkers bear off and 3 checkers on my 2 points. The other player had 0 checker bear off, 1 checker on the bar, 1 on my 3 point and an other one on my 4 point and he roll 3-4 and resign and i only get a gammon. With 2 of his checkers on my home board after he play and a shot for me to roll a double 2 or better with the dice (5 out of 36 chances) i had some backgammon chances. Even if i fail to roll a double with the dice, he can fail to get his last 2 checkers out if he roll low number with the dice. Again, i lost equity because my opponent resign without finishing the game.
This is a big problem with this site and this should be fixed by enable people to resign if the other player did not agree. Also apply the Crawford rule so match play can be fair.
|
|
terryhaig
Posts: 6
Registered: May, 2015
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Feb 5, 2016 2:13 AM |
| | I don't understand why an opponent can resign when he or she is facing a gammon. This violates the rules of backgammon
|
|
FlyOrDie
Posts: 485
Registered: Nov, 2001
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Feb 5, 2016 7:31 AM |
| | Could you please provide a generally accepted definition of what should be considered as 'facing a gammon' ?
Thank you.
|
|
terryhaig
Posts: 6
Registered: May, 2015
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Feb 27, 2016 2:23 PM |
| | Thank you. I am bearing off with only 6 stones to bear off. My opponent has 7 stones to get home. 3 are just outside my home. He resigns and I get 1 point.
|
|
DukeBedford
Posts: 10
Registered: Apr, 2014
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Mar 25, 2016 8:24 PM |
| | In my experience 'resigning' when your opponent is about to bear off and you have not borne any off any DOES (usually) result in a gammon being scored. My complaint is that quitting your browser (that is, quitting without actually resigning) does NOT produce a gammon. This just happened to me *again* when my opponent still had two men outside his inner board and I was about to bear off. This is cheating and it should not be allowed. I can't imagine that this situation is that hard for the servers to calculate.
|
|
DEVELOPER
Posts: 513
Registered: Sep, 2004
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Mar 29, 2016 10:34 AM |
| | Resigning or closing the browser window are the same: The program will calculate the odds if the game will be a gammon or not. If the possibility of a gammon is high enough, gammon scoring will be applied.
|
|
Caneta
Posts: 39
Registered: Jan, 2009
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Apr 11, 2016 9:25 PM |
| | Crawford Rule:
There is no justification to allow that there is a bet fold, fold as this makes no difference to the other player. Example: 4X3 on a starting five can not be fold; In a 3X2 starting 5 may be only one fold, and so on.
Give up to avoid backgammon:
Using the icon 'Give Up', it could never be allowed. It is the same to finish a football game before a penalty charge. utter frustration!
Connection loss:
In this case, the server should calculate what the most likely, if the game ends with backgammon win or not, and most likely should prevail.
Player loses on purpose to encourage the opponent to get more points:
This kind of situation can not help. The victory backgammon can not be sacrificed on the grounds that a player may favor his opponent, because this can be done the way it is today, just takes a little more time.
|
|
DukeBedford
Posts: 10
Registered: Apr, 2014
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Aug 13, 2017 8:01 PM |
| | I just had the same thing happen. I had borne off all but two men. My opponent still had five men outside his home board and had borne off 0. He resigned, I received credit for only a single game. He didn't close his browser, because he immediately asked for a return match. This seems like a fundamental bug in the scoring calculation.
|
|
DukeBedford
Posts: 10
Registered: Apr, 2014
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Aug 13, 2017 8:02 PM |
| | I just had the same thing happen. I had borne off all but two men. My opponent still had five men outside his home board and had borne off 0. He resigned, I received credit for only a single game. He didn't close his browser, because he immediately asked for a return match. This seems like a fundamental bug in the scoring calculation.
|
|
Owlbow
Posts: 1
Registered: Apr, 2018
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Apr 12, 2018 1:40 AM |
| | That's too bad. What can I do to make it right?
|
|
BadLuckBrian
Posts: 4
Registered: Mar, 2017
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: May 15, 2018 6:48 PM |
| | I'm another user frustrated when other players give up to avoid a gammon or backgammon. Not very sporting.
|
|
DukeBedford
Posts: 10
Registered: Apr, 2014
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Sep 4, 2018 4:57 PM |
| | And it just happened again. I had born off 4, my opponent still had checkers outside his home board. He quit, but I didn't get credit for a gammon. This CAN'T be that hard to fix!!
|
|
Doback78
Posts: 1
Registered: Mar, 2016
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Feb 16, 2019 7:10 PM |
| | Just happened to me as well. That is unfair because you know players do it on purpose because they know they will get out of it. And you are all right it should NOT be that hard to fix. It is things like that on this site that makes me want to find somewhere different to play
|
|
M.flyordie Backgammon
DogBite
Posts: 11
Registered: Jan, 2018
|
| | Re: Resign to avoid backgammon - unfair | Posted: Feb 26, 2019 3:04 PM |
| | This glitch encourages people to leave the game when behind. I do it now after it was done to me several times.
|
|
| Back to Topic List | Top of the page |
|
In the world of online backgammon, FlyOrDie is an interesting option with several assets. Let’s find out why you should give FlyOrDie Backgammon a try or not.
Presentation of FlyOrDie Backgammon
FlyOrDie like many other websites doesn’t only focus on backgammon. You will find many other games like blackjack, domino, gin rummy and many more. That means that many players are connected every day on the platform. Usually, around 500 of them are waiting for you to join the party. You can sign up or play as a guest, but you won’t have access to all the features if you don’t take the subscription, which is $2,08 per month. If you stay in the free mode you won’t be able to change the setting of the game, like the number of point, for example. The tournaments are also only available for the players with a subscription. We notice that you can play a match for 10 or 20 points when usually backgammon matches are only played until an odd number of points (9,17, 21). This detail makes us question the knowledge of the creators of the game about backgammon.
This is the big downside of Flyordie backgammon, because apart from that the platform is quite pleasant with nice graphics and interface.
The virtual board itself is nicely done, but we regret that there is no proper bar in the middle. The absence of the bar creates some confusion when you move the checkers around. Another con is that the board cannot be put on full-screen and the ratio on the window could be improved.
Our opinion on FlyOrDie backgammon
Play Backgammon Online Against People
Flyordie backgammon is a decent platform if you want to play many other games than backgammon and if you are ready to pay the $2,08 monthly subscription. If you are not willing to pay, we recommend you to go find another, totally free, online backgammon website. The reason is simply that you are too limited in your options if you stay on the free version of the software. Have a look in all our other reviews to find the online backgammon platform of your dream.
6.3
Pros
- - No registration needed
- - Available on desktop and mobile
- - Leaderboard available
Cons
- - Free to play but limited
- - Impossible to play for money
- - Tournament available only with subscription
